>>>>> "Robin" == Robin Smith <rasmith@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> writes: Naoto> Does this mean that the triplet <Stephanus page, section, Naoto> line> is not a unique citation in the TLG? Robin> That is correct. There are actually two volumes in the Stephanus Robin> edition, but the Stephanos volume number is not part of the standard Robin> citation (and does not appear in the TLG citation). For example, Robin> "11b1" is a citation both in the Euthyphro and in the Philebus. Thank you for your explanation. Naoto> If so, Aristotle should be the only author whose works Naoto> benefit from inter-work jump. (considering your comment Naoto> below) Robin> This is only a set of examples drawn from Plato and Aristotle. Robin> There probably are some authors (especially authors of only a few Robin> works) for whom unique citations do exist across works (including Robin> the trivial case of authors with a single work). What I'm trying to Robin> say is that any sort of cross-work jump would have to be based on Robin> the details of a particular author's case and is going to take a whole Robin> lot more than a few dozen lines of elisp to implement. I have no intention of writing programs for cross-work jump for all authors. However, writing a cross-work jump program for Aristotle (using Bekker page) should not be so difficult and benefit many scholars. So I will. The user still has to use the w key to select a work that does not have Bekker pages, but it should be acceptable. Robin> BTW, I've just noticed that the current version of the tlg utilities Robin> doesn't correctly read the citations in the second collection of Robin> Epigrams in Plato (tlg0059.idt work 41). In what way? I have just tried tlg0059.idt work 41, but it seems working. Another bug in version D? I attached my tlg0059.idt from version E.
Attachment:
tlg0059.idt.gz
Description: Binary data